If I’m being honest, I was prepared to hate on the air fryer until it went out of style. But now that I’ve tried the Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven, I’m convinced it may never go out of style. The TOA-65 includes a handy pull-out crumb tray (which does the job) and features interior sides coated with nonstick.
I spend every Thanksgiving and Christmas in the kitchen with my mom cooking for a family of 12, and have always been interested in finding new ways to speed up the process. This 1,800-watt powerhouse from Breville is cuisinart air fryer oven worth the splurge, so long as you have enough countertop real estate. Boasting an extra-large capacity, this mighty model can toasts nine slices of bread, fit most 9 x 13–inch pans and even roast a 14-pound turkey.
Our journalists combine independent research with (occasionally) over-the-top testing so you can make quick and confident buying decisions. Whether it’s finding great products or discovering helpful advice, we’ll help you get it right (the first time). Before becoming a cooking tools maven, she worked as a professional chef in New York City restaurants for seven years. What makes this Ninja “smart” is a thermometer that plugs into the unit for automatically cooking to precise temperatures.
The back also opens to give you easy access to the interior for cleaning. Its large nonstick sheet pan can cook chicken, beef, or shrimp and veggies for four in under 30 minutes. In addition to being an excellent toaster, this Cuisinart is one of the top air fryers you can buy. It was our former Best Overall until Cuisinart introduced a newer, digital model. Fortunately, the TOA-60 is still available and a wonderful option if you want to spend a little less than the TOA-65.
In addition to the matte black design with rose-gold colored knobs, it also comes in white and stainless steel. Aesthetics aside, this air fryer toaster oven performed well in our tests. Air fried wings took 20 minutes to crisp evenly, released from the air fryer basket easily and stayed juicy. We were pleased that there wasn’t any smoking during air frying and that the oven was easy to use overall.
In the Good Housekeeping Institute Kitchen Appliances and Innovation Lab, we’ve tested more than 20 different air fryer toaster ovens in addition to more than 40 standalone air fryers and 40 standalone toaster ovens. When we test the air frying function on appliances and air fryers, we cook 1 pound of chicken wings, 1 pound of frozen fries and 1 pound of fresh fries in each machine to see how quickly and evenly each crisps up. We also assess several ease-of-use features like the clarity of the control panel and how easy each appliance is to clean. Here are the best air fryer toaster ovens you buy, according to our testing.