Mummy bags are popular for both camping and backpacking, but rectangular bags are roomier and can offer an even better sleeping experience. Our top pick in this category is REI Co-op’s Siesta Hooded 20, which replaces the Siesta 25 for 2023. For a reasonable $139, you get a high-quality bag with a useful 20-degree temperature rating, which is great for three-season car camping in a variety of conditions. Added up, the Siesta is comfy, well appointed, and a fantastic value.
The hood is the nicest add-on because it helps retain heat and adds comfort. It’s cinchable, with a simple nylon cord and plastic toggle that aren’t that fancy but get the job done. The nicest comfort touch is the added fleece in the footbox; it adds a touch of coziness to an already plush and comfortable bag.
You will love this extra layer of comfort between you and your sleeping pad when you are in your family tent. Meant for 30- to 50-degree nights, this rectangular bag is roomy in the legs and supremely comfortable. It is fleecy soft inner lining and it rolls up and ties with attached cords. That said, the all-in-one answer comes with some compromises. In the end, the temperature rating does have value and you should use it as a basic guideline.
I also love the snag-free zipper and the handy hidden pocket. When it comes to packed size, the Brazos lands right in the middle out of all of the bags we tested. We also scored each bag on how easy it rolled up and fit into its storage bag. It rolls up easily and fits into its stuff sack with a little bit of effort. It’s also quite a stretch, but it could double as a backpacking bag if you’re in a pinch.
The Big Bay also has a cinchable hood, no-snag zipper and plush collar, plus it allows for foot ventilation, just like the Forte. Anytime a company adds features or upgraded components to a sleeping coleman canopy bag, it adds to the cost. When you’re new to camping, the goal is to find a sleeping bag that has the features you need and none of the ones you don’t, which is what the Big Bay offers.